THE CONDO BOOK PROJECT

1438 Third Avenue Condo. Maison East (Maison East)

1438 Third Avenue, Manhattan, NY 10028

Compare

Overview

Maison East is a 147-unit condo conversion in Manhattan, with 1 commercial unit.

  • Offering plan: Accepted August 2006 · 342 pages
  • Finishes: Hardwood floors, laminate kitchen countertops, vinyl covered melamine cabinets and through-wall PTAC units for heating and cooling
  • Prices: $1,093 a square foot on average, as first offered; $136.8 million in all
  • Common charges: $362–$701 a month, the sponsor's first-year estimate
  • Utilities: Electricity paid by the owner; gas, heat, hot water and water and sewer in the common charges p. 306
  • Developer: Broad Street Development Corp; principals Raymond Chalme
  • Sponsor: 81st And 3rd Owner LLC, represented by Cutler Minikes & Adelman LLP
  • Neighborhood: Upper East Side, Manhattan
  • Subway: 5-minute walk to 86 St (Q); 6 minutes to 86 St (4, 5, 6)
  • Amendments: 19, the latest in April 2009
  1. AcceptedAugust 2006
  2. 19 amendments
  3. First sale
  4. Latest sale

Sales

93 of 147 units sold (63%)

$149.6 millionin sales
$1,757/SFaverage sale price
May 2007 – August 2009first to latest sale
UnitSoldPrice
4BAug 10, 2009$1,282,995
4AJul 30, 2009$661,863
5AMay 20, 2009$670,000
2EMay 15, 2009$1,255,000
2BMar 17, 2009$1,756,481
25AMar 12, 2009$845,000
2AMar 10, 2009$650,000
14COct 7, 2008$1,914,310
6AAug 22, 2008$812,480
5BJul 21, 2008$2,031,409
31AJul 1, 2008$5,000,000
3BJun 25, 2008$2,642,359
7AJun 18, 2008$819,691
8AMay 13, 2008$827,483
15AMay 1, 2008$931,699
5EApr 29, 2008$2,189,238
9BApr 22, 2008$2,031,409
9AApr 14, 2008$883,332
9EMar 31, 2008$1,909,219
4EMar 25, 2008$2,036,500
6EMar 12, 2008$2,061,956
8BMar 12, 2008$2,046,683
6BMar 11, 2008$2,051,774
COMMar 6, 2008$4,000,000
8EFeb 29, 2008$2,112,869
30BFeb 29, 2008$3,156,575
7BFeb 19, 2008$2,026,318
7EFeb 19, 2008$2,204,511
26AJan 30, 2008$1,023,341
29EJan 18, 2008$2,846,009
13AJan 15, 2008$911,334
29BJan 14, 2008$3,003,838
30EJan 11, 2008$3,003,838
24BDec 19, 2007$3,207,488
28BDec 14, 2007$2,347,066
28EDec 14, 2007$1,135,349
28ADec 7, 2007$1,033,524
24ADec 6, 2007$1,013,159
10ADec 5, 2007$896,060
18BNov 26, 2007$2,082,321
15ENov 16, 2007$2,077,230
18ANov 16, 2007$946,973
18ENov 13, 2007$2,341,975
22AOct 30, 2007$957,155
25BOct 29, 2007$923,044
26COct 29, 2007$1,578,288
26BOct 25, 2007$934,754
26EOct 24, 2007$1,695,386
11EOct 19, 2007$2,016,135
22BOct 15, 2007$2,224,876
22EOct 15, 2007$2,240,150
16AOct 10, 2007$900,133
16EOct 1, 2007$2,092,504
19CSep 28, 2007$1,473,917
16BSep 24, 2007$2,102,686
19ESep 21, 2007$1,578,288
13ESep 19, 2007$1,501,919
27ASep 17, 2007$1,028,433
11ASep 10, 2007$901,151
19BSep 10, 2007$890,969
25ESep 5, 2007$2,199,420
13BAug 27, 2007$868,567
13CAug 27, 2007$1,397,548
14AAug 24, 2007$916,425
21BAug 17, 2007$909,297
27BAug 15, 2007$2,204,511
20AAug 14, 2007$941,881
27EAug 13, 2007$2,240,150
12AAug 10, 2007$896,060
20EAug 10, 2007$2,199,420
20BJul 24, 2007$2,061,956
10EJul 17, 2007$2,031,409
10BJul 13, 2007$1,960,131
21AJul 12, 2007$933,735
25CJul 10, 2007$942,732
28DJul 3, 2007$789,247
14EJul 2, 2007$930,270
23AJul 2, 2007$934,754
15BJun 25, 2007$1,955,040
21CJun 21, 2007$1,501,919
21EJun 21, 2007$1,606,289
12CJun 15, 2007$1,384,820
12EJun 14, 2007$1,522,284
23EJun 14, 2007$2,158,690
12BJun 13, 2007$865,513
17BJun 12, 2007$2,163,781
17AJun 8, 2007$926,608
17EJun 1, 2007$2,051,774
3EMay 31, 2007$925,538
14BMay 31, 2007$873,659
24EMay 25, 2007$999,521
3AMay 24, 2007$800,000
19AMay 24, 2007$832,997
Every sale: 93 recorded sales, with price and dateGet Full Access

From city records (ACRIS), through Aug 31, 2026.

Common Charges & First-Year Budget

Property Taxes

The plan's first-year tax estimate, checked against the city's real bills.

HomePlan's estimateCurrent
2A$15,501$16,621FY2026
3A$10,565$13,730FY2026
4A$10,565$11,327FY2026
5A$10,483$11,240FY2026
6A$10,483$13,625FY2026
7A$10,483$13,625FY2026
8A$10,483$13,625FY2026
9A$11,284$12,098FY2026
10A$11,284$12,098FY2026
11A$11,284$38,331FY2026
12A$11,284$12,098FY2026
13A$11,284$12,098FY2026
14A$11,284$12,098FY2026
15A$11,284$14,665FY2026
16A$11,284$14,665FY2026
17A$11,284$14,665FY2026
18A$11,284$14,665FY2026
19A$11,284$14,665FY2026
20A$11,284$14,665FY2026
21A$11,284$12,098FY2026
22A$11,284$12,098FY2026
23A$11,284$39,246FY2026
24A$11,284$14,665FY2026
25A$11,284$12,098FY2026
26A$11,284$12,098FY2026
27A$11,284$14,665FY2026
28A$11,284$12,098FY2026
31A$11,284$80,862FY2026
2B$17,061$46,019FY2026
3B$8,815$32,106FY2026
4B$8,815$10,089FY2026
5B$10,619$24,602FY2026
6B$10,619$24,602FY2026
7B$10,619$24,602FY2026
8B$10,619$24,602FY2026
9B$11,541$26,143FY2026
10B$11,541$26,232FY2026
12B$11,541$12,374FY2026
13B$11,541$12,374FY2026
14B$11,541$14,999FY2026
15B$11,541$26,232FY2026
16B$11,541$26,232FY2026
17B$11,541$26,232FY2026
18B$11,541$26,232FY2026
19B$11,541$14,999FY2026
20B$11,541$31,797FY2026
21B$11,541$14,999FY2026
22B$11,541$31,797FY2026
24B$11,541$38,518FY2026
25B$11,541$12,417FY2026
26B$11,541$12,374FY2026
27B$11,541$27,148FY2026
28B$11,541$26,926FY2026
29B$16,437$41,578FY2026
30B$16,437$34,302FY2026
12C$11,772$18,743FY2026
13C$11,772$18,903FY2026
14C$11,772$24,269FY2026
19C$11,772$18,888FY2026
21C$11,772$22,735FY2026
25C$12,626$16,408FY2026
26C$12,626$19,674FY2026
28D$10,660$11,208FY2026
2E$15,637$32,078FY2026
3E$13,752$14,745FY2026
4E$13,752$25,882FY2026
5E$13,752$25,781FY2026
6E$13,752$25,593FY2026
7E$13,752$25,781FY2026
8E$13,752$25,781FY2026
9E$12,247$25,563FY2026
10E$12,992$25,577FY2026
11E$12,992$30,809FY2026
12E$12,992$23,389FY2026
13E$12,992$19,296FY2026
14E$12,992$16,884FY2026
15E$12,992$25,359FY2026
16E$12,992$25,417FY2026
17E$12,992$25,417FY2026
18E$12,992$30,739FY2026
19E$12,992$19,310FY2026
20E$12,992$25,577FY2026
21E$12,992$19,224FY2026
22E$12,992$25,417FY2026
23E$13,820$26,464FY2026
24E$13,820$14,816FY2026
25E$13,820$26,421FY2026
26E$13,820$24,641FY2026
27E$13,820$26,247FY2026
28E$13,820$14,816FY2026
29E$16,830$30,987FY2026
30E$16,830$30,987FY2026

The plan's estimate is the sponsor's guess for year one. The city's bill is the real one, from the Department of Finance.

Each home's estimate, city bills and tax breaksGet Full Access

Closing Costs

The buyer pays the NYC and NY State transfer taxes, which a seller usually pays.

Counsel's extra charges
  • $200.00: ACRIS document preparation feep. 68
  • $250.00: closing of sale with bank financingp. 68
  • $500.00: attendance fee for closing outside counsel's officep. 68
  • $700.00: attendance fee for closing outside Manhattanp. 68
  • $250.00: adjourned closingp. 68
Transfer taxes
Paid by the purchaserNew York City and State transfer taxes, by law the seller's, shift to the buyer in a sponsor salep. 7
Working capital
“two (2) months estimated common charges”Contribution to the condominium's working capital fundp. 69
NYC Equalization and Assessment Form filing fee
$75.00p. 21

Not listed: title insurance, mortgage tax, lender fees, mansion tax.

All 8 closing costs in the plan, with their pagesGet Full Access

Amendments

Amendment 19 Apr 28, 2009

Nineteenth Amendment updates unsold unit listings, common charges, board composition, and 2009 budget with 5% common charge increase effective February 1, 2009.

  • Aggregate monthly common charges for residential unsold units: $3,272.70
  • Aggregate monthly real estate taxes for residential unsold units: $5,479.57
  • 2009 Budget includes 5% increase in common charges effective February 1, 2009
  • Board of Managers: Gregory Olsen (President), David Clary (Vice President/Treasurer), David Blittner (Vice President/Secretary), Harold Malone, Perri Freeman, Richard B. Adelman (Sponsor Representative), [Vacant] (Commercial Unit Representative)
  • Resident Owners have controlled Board of Managers since January 9, 2008
  • Certified Financial Statements for period May 1, 2007 to December 31, 2007 attached
  • Plan may not be used after twelve months following Filing Date of this Amendment unless further amended or extended
  • Sponsor current on all financial obligations; no financial obligations becoming due within twelve months

Amendment 18 Sep 29, 2008

Units 2B and 2E are reconfigured with new square footage, common charges, and prices.

  • Unit 2B reconfigured from 1,456 to 1,846 sq.ft.; price raised to $1,846,000
  • Unit 2E reconfigured from 1,771 to 1,381 sq.ft.; price lowered to $1,555,000
  • Unit 2B monthly common charges increased to $1,559.62
  • Unit 2E monthly common charges decreased to $1,087.14
  • Unit 2B percentage interest in common elements increased to 1.8452%
  • Unit 2E percentage interest in common elements decreased to 1.5604%
  • Unit 2B will have new kitchen, drywall, relocated laundry, bathroom removed
  • Floor plans and Declaration amended to reflect reconfigured units

Amendment 17 May 12, 2008

Units 3B and 3D are combined into one larger Unit 3B with renovations to be completed by the Sponsor.

  • Units 3B and 3D combined into new Unit 3B on third floor
  • Combined unit square footage increased from 1,469 + 739 = 2,208 sq ft
  • Bedrooms increased from 2.0 + 1.0 to 4.0
  • Bathrooms increased from 2.0 + 1.0 to 4.0
  • Common elements percentage interest increased from 1.0381% + 0.5223% to 1.5604%
  • Sponsor to install new drywall, kitchen, bathrooms, doors, wood floors, and laundry closet with washer/dryer
  • New tax lot number to be filed; condominium floor plans to be amended
  • Attorney address for Richard B. Adelman now 150 White Plains Road, Suite 106, Tarrytown, NY 10591

Amendment 16 May 5, 2008

Price of Unit 5B changed to $2,150,000.00

Amendment 15 Feb 27, 2008

Commercial unit sale to 1438 Third Retail LLC with closing in March 2008.

  • Commercial Unit to be sold to 1438 Third Retail LLC (Zeckendorf Development entity)
  • Commercial Unit closing expected in March 2008

Amendment 14 Oct 19, 2007

Fourteenth Amendment confirms first closing occurred May 24, 2007, establishes reserve and working capital funds, lists unsold units with current prices and monthly charges, and sets board composition.

  • First closing took place May 24, 2007 at Wachtel & Mayer LLP offices
  • Sponsor sold Unit 3A to Board of Managers for superintendent's apartment
  • Capital Reserve Fund of $3,695,221 established with $2,463,481 net funding after sponsor credits
  • Working capital fund of $146,814.93 funded at Bank of New York
  • Unsold units aggregate monthly common charges $46,733.18, real estate taxes $84,877.21
  • Real estate tax rate for Class 2 properties set at 11.928% effective July 2007–June 2008 tax year
  • Board of Managers: Raymond Chahne (President), Hy Chahne (Vice President), Daniel Blanco (Secretary/Treasurer)
  • First Meeting of Unit Owners scheduled for October 9, 2007

Amendment 13 Apr 25, 2007

Purchase prices for 8 units have been changed.

  • Unit 2B price changed to $1,725,000
  • Unit 3B price changed to $2,650,000
  • Unit 5B price changed to $1,995,000
  • Unit 6B price changed to $2,015,000
  • Unit 14C price changed to $1,995,000
  • Unit 2E price changed to $2,115,000
  • Unit 5E price changed to $2,150,000
  • Unit 9E price changed to $1,875,000

Amendment 12 Apr 17, 2007

Schedule A offering prices updated; cellar playroom created from commercial unit space; budget and taxes revised for July 1, 2007 commencement.

  • Schedule A offering prices revised
  • Cellar playroom created as Residential Common Element; Commercial Unit reduced by 168 square feet
  • Common charges for Residential Units approximately 9.75% greater than original plan due to payroll increases
  • Real estate taxes projected at $1,967,102 for first year based on $16,155,000 assessed valuation
  • Schedule B budget revised for July 1, 2007 commencement date
  • Condominium Declaration corrected to reference concrete slab floors and ceilings instead of wood joist
  • Plan declared effective with 51 of 95 Residential Units under purchase agreement (53.68%)

Amendment 11 Mar 19, 2007

Prices of two unsold units were changed.

  • Unit 13C price raised to $1,372,500
  • Unit 13E price raised to $1,475,000

Amendment 10 Mar 12, 2007

Tenth Amendment changes purchase prices for 16 units across multiple unit types.

  • Unit 2B price changed to $1,650,000
  • Unit 3B price changed to $1,670,000
  • Unit 4B price changed to $1,690,000
  • Unit 5B price changed to $1,950,000
  • Unit 6B price changed to $1,970,000
  • Unit 7B price changed to $1,990,000
  • Unit 8B price changed to $2,010,000
  • Unit 2E price changed to $1,995,000
  • Schedule A prices increased for 1 home (median +5.2%): 3D $765,000 → $805,000

Amendment 9 Mar 7, 2007

32 pairs of units combined into larger units, prices increased for certain units, and escrow bank changed.

  • 32 unit combinations created, reducing total units from 128 to 95 for sale
  • Combined units total 2,582 additional square feet in aggregate
  • Prices increased for certain units (see new Schedule A)
  • Unit 2E adds 300 sq. ft. terrace previously omitted
  • Unit 9E corrected to 1,150 sq. ft. (was shown as 1,267 sq. ft.)
  • Unit 31A receives 844 sq. ft. of roof as Limited Common Elements
  • Unit 19E bathroom count corrected to 2.5
  • Escrow account moved from Wachvel & Masyr to North Fork Bank, 424 Madison Avenue

Amendment 8 Feb 9, 2007

Purchase prices for 18 units have been changed.

  • Unit 10B price changed to $1,945,000
  • Unit 11B price changed to $1,965,000
  • Unit 15B price changed to $2,045,000
  • Unit 20B price changed to $2,145,000
  • Unit 23B price changed to $2,205,000
  • Unit 27B price changed to $2,285,000
  • Unit 28B price changed to $2,305,000
  • Units 16B, 17B, 18B, 22B, 16C, 17C, 18C, 22C prices updated
  • Schedule A prices increased for 7 homes (median +2.7%): 16B $991,807 → $1,016,417; 17B $999,190 → $1,026,262; 18B $921,743 → $1,036,106; 22B $1,041,028 → $1,075,483; ...
  • Schedule A prices decreased for 1 home (median -4.8%): 18C $1,123,257 → $1,068,894

Amendment 7 Feb 5, 2007

Purchase prices for 13 units are increased.

  • Unit 10D price increased to $909,114
  • Unit 15E price increased to $1,136,989
  • Unit 15D price increased to $933,011
  • Unit 16E price increased to $1,142,448
  • Unit 16D price increased to $942,552
  • Unit 17E price increased to $2,100,000
  • Unit 9E price increased to $1,462,500
  • Unit 19E price increased to $1,582,500
  • Schedule A prices increased for 7 homes (median +1.5%): 10D $895,443 → $909,114; 15D $919,489 → $933,011; 16D $928,990 → $942,552; 10E $1,069,557 → $1,085,886; ...

Amendment 6 Jan 26, 2007

Purchase prices for 74 units across multiple floor plans are increased.

  • Schedule A prices increased for 49 homes (median +7.0%): 2A $880,000 → $915,000; 4A $805,000 → $860,000; 5A $805,000 → $865,000; 6A $810,000 → $870,000; ...

Amendment 5 Jan 23, 2007

Seven pairs of vacant units are combined into new larger units with updated pricing and floor plans.

  • Units 9C and portion of 9D combined into new Unit 9C
  • Portion of Unit 9D and Unit 9E combined into new Unit 9E
  • Units 14C and 14D combined into new Unit 14C
  • Units 17D and 17E combined into new Unit 17E
  • Units 24B, 24C, and 24D combined into new Unit 24B
  • Units 26C and portion of 26D combined into new Unit 26C
  • Portion of Unit 26D and Unit 26E combined into new Unit 26E
  • Total units now 127; total Price to Non-Tenant Offerees is $140,367,615

Amendment 4 Jan 5, 2007

Prices of 9 unsold units increased.

  • Unit 9B price increased to $833,000
  • Unit 12B price increased to $850,000
  • Unit 13B price increased to $853,000
  • Unit 14B price increased to $858,000
  • Unit 19B price increased to $883,000
  • Unit 21B price increased to $893,000
  • Unit 22B price increased to $898,000
  • Unit 25B price increased to $913,000
  • Schedule A prices increased for 9 homes (median +0.1%): 9B $832,120 → $833,000; 12B $847,130 → $850,000; 13B $851,870 → $853,000; 14B $856,610 → $858,000; ...

Amendment 3 Dec 20, 2006

Twelve pairs of vacant units combined into single larger units, reducing total units offered from 145 to 133.

  • Units 11B and 11C combined into Unit 11B
  • Units 12C and portion of 12D combined into Unit 12C
  • Units 12D portion and 12E combined into Unit 12E
  • Units 19C and portion of 19D combined into Unit 19C
  • Units 19D portion and 19E combined into Unit 19E
  • Units 20B and 20C combined into Unit 20B
  • Units 21C and portion of 21D combined into Unit 21C
  • Total units now 133; Price to Tenant-Offerees: $123,174,033; Price to Non-Tenant Offerees: $139,434,133

Amendment 2 Dec 11, 2006

Purchase prices for multiple units increased.

  • Schedule A prices increased for 55 homes (median +0.1%): 2A $879,127 → $880,000; 3A $796,138 → $800,000; 4A $801,591 → $805,000; 5A $800,055 → $805,000; ...

Amendment 1 Dec 6, 2006

Amendment combines 5 pairs of vacant units into 5 larger units, corrects a tenant price for Unit 15C, raises prices on 4 units, changes the condominium name to Maison East Condominium, and updates aggregate pricing and reserve fund amounts.

  • 5 vacant unit pairs combined: Units 10B+10C→10B, 11D+11E→11E, 15B+15C→15B, 25D+25E→25E, 27B+27C→27B
  • Total units offered reduced to 142
  • Price to Tenant-Offerees corrected for Unit 15C to reflect tenant discount
  • Unit prices increased: 29A to $959,000, 30A to $964,000, 30B to $1,345,000, 29C to $1,295,000
  • New Price to Tenant-Offerees: $123,174,027
  • New Price to Non-Tenant Offerees: $137,484,704
  • Capital Reserve Fund updated to $3,695,221
  • Condominium name changed from "The 1438 Third Avenue Condominium" to "Maison East Condominium"
  • Schedule A prices increased for 4 homes (median +3.7%): 29A $924,383 → $959,000; 30A $929,780 → $964,000; 30B $1,309,802 → $1,345,000; 29C $1,260,100 → $1,295,000
What each amendment changed, line by lineGet Full Access

Team

Sponsor
81st And 3rd Owner LLC
Principals
Raymond Chalme
Tax estimate
Marcus & Pollack LLPPrepared the first-year real estate tax projection
Construction lender
American International GroupLender on the mortgage and building loan agreement recorded September 2005 in ACRIS; $148.8 million recorded
Property reports
CMA Design Studio, P.C., Ambient Group, Inc., Avcon Design GroupPrepared the plan's description of the property and its condition · Named on p. 104
Title agency
Title Associates, Inc.The sponsor's title company for buyers; you can choose another · Agent for Stewart Title Insurance Company · Named on p. 71

Zoning

Zoning district
C1-9

Today's zoning, from city data (PLUTO 26v2).

Nearby