350 Butler Condominium (The Butler Collection)
350 Butler Street, Brooklyn, NY 11217
Overview
The Butler Collection is a 34-unit condo in Brooklyn.
- Offering plan: Accepted May 2022 · 352 pages · floor plans on page 81
- Finishes: Granite kitchen countertops, Bosch, JennAir and Summit appliances, a washer and dryer in each apartment, Waterworks bathroom fittings and split-system units for heating and cooling
- Prices: $1,459 a square foot on average, as first offered; $61.1 million in all
- Common charges: $224–$1,520 a month, the sponsor's first-year estimate
- Developer: The Brooklyn Home Company; principals William Caleo and Lindsay Caleo
- Sponsor: 346 Butler LLC, represented by Marcus Attorneys Pllc
- Neighborhood: Park Slope, Brooklyn
- Subway: 5-minute walk to Union St (R); 7 minutes to Atlantic Av-Barclays Ctr (2, 3, 4, 5, B, D, N, Q, R)
- Amendments: 9, the latest in July 2025
- Units
- 34 residential
- Neighborhood
- Park Slope, Brooklyn
- Subway
- 5 min walk to Union St RAtlantic Av-Barclays Ctr 2 3 4 5 B D N Q R, 7 min
- Developer
- The Brooklyn Home Company
- Principals
- William Caleo, Lindsay Caleo
- Average $/sf
- $1,459Homes in Schedule A, as first offered
- Common charges
- $224–$1,520 a monthSponsor's first-year estimate in Schedule A, From October 1, 2022 To September 30, 2023
- Offering price
- $61.1 million total
- Floor plans
- Page 81 of the plan
- SubmittedMay 2022
- AcceptedMay 2022
- 9 amendments
- First sale
- Latest sale
Units & Prices
Sales
From city records (ACRIS), through Jun 30, 2026.
First-Year Budget
From our research: NYC Co-op and Condo Tax Abatement: Is It Worth Paying Prevailing Wage? (Board Calculator)
Property Taxes
The plan's first-year tax estimate, checked against the city's real bills for 33 homes.
Each home's estimate, city bills and tax breaksSee it free →Closing Costs
The buyer pays the NYC and NY State transfer taxes, which a seller usually pays.
All 7 closing costs in the plan, with their pagesSee it free →The Building
Amendments
Amendment 9 2025
This amendment extends the offering plan term for twelve months and updates unsold unit and financial information as of June 1, 2025.
- Plan term extended for 12 months from amendment date
- One unsold residential unit (10A) listed at $1,300,000
- One unsold storage space listed at $15,000
- Sponsor transferred Board of Managers control to unit owners on April 25, 2024
- Aggregate monthly Common Charges for unsold units: $840.47
- Aggregate monthly real estate taxes for unsold units: $1,536.21
- 2024 condominium financial statements not yet available
- William Caleo and Lyndsay Caleo are principals in 524 Halsey Condominium
Amendment 8 Nov 14, 2024
Offering price amended for Unit 9A.
Amendment 6 Apr 30, 2024
Offering prices for two units are amended.
- Unit 8B price raised to $2,495,000.00
- Unit PH1 price raised to $4,325,000.00
Amendment 5 Feb 9, 2024
First unit closing occurred on December 12, 2023 with temporary certificate of occupancy; $6,500 escrowed for final certificate work.
- First unit closing occurred December 12, 2023
- Temporary certificate of occupancy issued November 29, 2023
- $6,500 deposited in escrow for final certificate of occupancy work
- Declaration recorded September 13, 2023
- Working capital fund balance $51,645.12 as of February 3, 2024
- Unit real estate tax assessment begun by NYC Department of Finance
- First unit owner meeting has not yet occurred; Sponsor controls Board of Managers
Amendment 4 Sep 28, 2023
This amendment extends the offering plan term for six months and provides updated financial information as of the filing date.
- Term of offering plan extended for six (6) months from filing date
- All 30 units remain unsold; no closings have occurred
- Estimated aggregate monthly Common Charges for unsold units: $33,352.17 ($400,226.00 annually)
- Estimated aggregate monthly real estate taxes for unsold units: $36,794.17 ($441,530.00 annually)
- Declaration and Floor Plans recorded September 13, 2023
- No unit owner meetings held; Sponsor controls Board of Managers
- No financial statements available; condominium will operate under Budget from Second Amendment
Amendment 3 2023
The plan is declared effective after securing purchase agreements for ten residential units representing approximately 30% of the thirty-four units offered.
- Plan declared effective
- Ten residential units (approximately 30% of 34 units) have accepted purchase agreements
- Sponsor affirms all counted purchasers are bona fide and independent of sponsor
- No material changes to first-year budget since plan was accepted for filing on May 2, 2022
Amendment 2 Jan 30, 2023
This Second Amendment changes the managing agent, updates unit prices and tax projections, adjusts the first closing date to July 1, 2023, and increases the first-year budget by approximately 49.50%.
- Managing Agent changed from First Class Management, Inc. to Monarch Realty Group
- Amended offering prices for units
- First closing date projected as on or about July 1, 2023
- Assessed value of building decreased from $5,048,247 to $4,692,936
- First year real estate taxes increased from $329,416 to $441,530 (approximately 34% increase)
- Budget increased approximately 49.50%; labor costs increased from $113,600 to $222,482 per year
- Unit PH2 area corrected to include bulkhead square footage
- Common interest percentages amended for Units PH1 and PH2
- Schedule A prices increased for 7 homes (median +2.5%): 7A $2,499,000 → $2,625,000; 7B $2,630,000 → $2,675,000; 8A $2,400,000 → $2,415,000; 8B $2,515,000 → $2,575,000; ...
- Schedule A prices decreased for 17 homes (median -6.5%): 1C $850,000 → $795,000; 2A $1,400,000 → $1,275,000; 2B $1,345,000 → $1,285,000; 2C $995,000 → $895,000; ...
Amendment 1 2022
Amendment updates offering prices, unit specifications, first closing date to January 1, 2023, real estate tax projections, and first-year budget.
- Offering prices amended
- First unit closing/commencement of condominium operations projected for on or about January 1, 2023
- Real estate tax projections updated: first year taxes decreased from $432,357 to $329,416; second year increased from $617,653 to $619,269
- Estimated assessed value of building remains $5,048,247; tax rate increased from 12.235% to 12.267%
- Schedule A budget increased approximately 15.44%
- Shared amenities income increased from $7,000 to $8,050 per year
- Unit 1D and PH2 areas corrected; Unit 9A terrace and PH1 balconies corrected; Unit 1D bedroom count corrected
- Percentage of common interest for units unchanged
- Schedule A prices increased for 29 homes (median +10.9%): 2A $1,295,000 → $1,400,000; 2B $1,280,000 → $1,345,000; 2C $960,000 → $995,000; 2D $1,595,000 → $1,699,000; ...
Team
- Sponsor
- 346 Butler LLC
- Developer
- The Brooklyn Home CompanyReported by cityrealty.com
- Principals
- William Caleo, Lindsay Caleo
- Counsel
- Marcus Attorneys Pllc
- Tax estimate
- Metropolitan Realty ExemptionsPrepared the first-year real estate tax projection
- General contractor
- Titan Realty & ConstructionHeld the general construction permit on DOB job 322084882
From our research: What Does a Title Agency Do, and How Do You Pick One for a NYC Condo?
Zoning
- Zoning district
- C4-4D
- Special district
- Special Gowanus Mixed-Use District (G)
Today's zoning, from city data (PLUTO 26v2).
Nearby
- 137 4th Avenue Condominiumnext door · 7 units · 2021
- 371 Douglass Street Condominiumnext door · 3 units · 2022
- 640 Baltic Street Condominiumnext door · 2 units · 2020
- 613 Baltic Street Condominiumnext door · 44 units · 10 parking · 2016
- 665 Degraw Street Condominiumnext door · 3 units · 2025
- 601 Baltic Condominiumnext door · 21 units · 2023
Free in ChatGPT or Claude
Ask Claude or ChatGPT about The Butler Collection
The fastest way to know any condo or co-op
Get Connected →