THE CONDO BOOK PROJECT

58 Saint Marks Place Condominium (Saint Marks Place)

58 Saint Marks Place, Brooklyn, NY 11217

Compare

Overview

Saint Marks Place is a 105-unit condo in Brooklyn, with 41 parking units, 53 storage units and 1 commercial unit.

  • Offering plan: Accepted August 2020 · 507 pages · floor plans on page 47
  • Finishes: Engineered wood floors, stone kitchen countertops, Bosch and Thermador appliances, a washer and dryer in each apartment, Signature bathroom fittings and a VRF heat pump system for heating and cooling
  • Prices: $1,509 a square foot on average, as first offered; $200 million in all
  • Common charges: $349–$5,751 a month, the sponsor's first-year estimate
  • Developer: Avdoo & Partners Development; principals Shlomo Avdoo and Yosi Cohen
  • Sponsor: 4th Avenue Development Owner LLC, represented by Marans Newman Tsolis & Nazinitsky LLC
  • Subway: 4-minute walk to Atlantic Av-Barclays Ctr (2, 3, 4, 5, B, D, N, Q, R); 7 minutes to Bergen St (2, 3)
  • Amendments: 5, the latest in November 2022
  1. SubmittedNovember 2020
  2. AcceptedAugust 2020
  3. 5 amendments
  4. First sale
  5. Latest sale

Sales

100 of 106homes sold (94%)
Every sale: 100 homes, with price and dateSee it free →

From city records (ACRIS), through Aug 31, 2026.

First-Year Budget

From our research: NYC Co-op and Condo Tax Abatement: Is It Worth Paying Prevailing Wage? (Board Calculator)

Ask Claude or ChatGPT: How do Saint Marks Place's common charges compare with similar buildings? →

Property Taxes

The plan's first-year tax estimate, checked against the city's real bills for 5 homes.

Each home's estimate, city bills and tax breaksSee it free →

Closing Costs

The buyer pays the NYC and NY State transfer taxes, which a seller usually pays.

All 4 closing costs in the plan, with their pagesSee it free →

Amendments

Amendment 4 Feb 3, 2022

Amendment revises Schedule A with new unit prices, updates first-year operating period to February 1, 2022 – January 31, 2023, and discloses increased real estate tax liability due to higher 2022/2023 assessment.

  • First Year of Operations changed to February 1, 2022 – January 31, 2023
  • First Year tax liability increased to $2,095,793.93 from previously disclosed $1,768,122.00
  • 2022/2023 tax assessment shows $2,521,960.54 liability; 2021/2022 shows $1,499,160.68
  • Sponsor pursuing appeals on assessment errors with Department of Finance and Tax Commission
  • New prices set for 47 units ranging from $17,500 to $3,100,000
  • TCO expected imminently with closings to commence shortly
  • Appeals decision on 2022/2023 taxes may take several years
  • Schedule A prices increased for 4 homes (median +3.4%): 301 $1,475,000 → $1,525,000; 605 $925,000 → $995,000; 902 $2,125,000 → $2,175,000; PH 1105 $3,000,000 → $3,100,000

Amendment 3 Dec 13, 2021

Prices for 69 units and parking spaces updated.

  • Unit 516 (3 BR penthouse with terrace) priced at $4,650,000.00
  • Penthouses PH1101, PH1105, PH1106 priced at $2,925,000.00, $3,000,000.00, $3,175,000.00
  • Parking spaces range from $15,000.00 to $45,000.00
  • Storage units priced from $15,000.00 to $27,000.00
  • Common charges and real estate tax estimates provided for first full year (January 1, 2022 - December 31, 2022)
  • Schedule A prices increased for 11 homes (median +1.2%): 301 $1,445,000 → $1,475,000; 306 $640,000 → $645,000; 401 $1,470,000 → $1,500,000; 406 $650,000 → $655,000; ...

Amendment 2 Nov 19, 2021

Prices updated for 46 units across the building.

  • Unit prices adjusted for 46 units ranging from $17,500 to $5,000,000
  • Revised Schedule A and Schedule A-1 attached reflecting new pricing
  • Common charges and estimated real estate taxes recalculated for affected units
  • Schedule A prices increased for 18 homes (median +3.6%): 101 $550,000 → $595,000; 301 $1,395,000 → $1,445,000; 306 $605,000 → $640,000; 401 $1,425,000 → $1,470,000; ...

Amendment 1 Nov 18, 2020

Amendment reduces residential units from 105 to 100, updates pricing and common charges, adds storage and parking spaces with EV charging, revises the first-year budget, and establishes reserve fund requirements.

  • Residential units reduced from 105 to 100; 19 named units removed and redesignated
  • Storage Spaces 66 through 93 added; some full height (FH)
  • Purchase prices, square footage, common interests, and common charges updated in Schedule A and A-1
  • NEMA 14-30 receptacle with 6 kW electric vehicle charging installed at each parking space
  • Two parking spaces in single stacker offered for combined price of $200,000.00
  • First-year budget revised from $1,309,374.19 to $1,270,871.47 plus $88,162.48 sponsor-funded replacement reserves
  • Resident Manager Unit changed to Unit 315 with transfer price of $1,075,000
  • Reserve Fund requirement set at $93,162.48 for first year, increasing 10% annually, with sponsor funding any shortfall
  • Schedule A prices increased for 31 homes (median +3.1%): 301 $1,380,000 → $1,395,000; 305 $605,000 → $625,000; 306 $585,000 → $605,000; 401 $1,400,000 → $1,425,000; ...
  • Schedule A prices decreased for 5 homes (median -3.4%): 315 $1,100,000 → $1,050,000; 415 $1,120,000 → $1,075,000; 515 $1,140,000 → $1,125,000; PH 1103 $3,800,000 → $3,700,000; ...
What each amendment changed, line by lineSee it free →

Team

Sponsor
4th Avenue Development Owner LLC
Principals
Shlomo Avdoo, Yosi Cohen
Tax estimate
Tuchman, Korngold, Weiss, Liebman & Lindemann, LLPPrepared the first-year real estate tax projection
Construction lender
Bank Leumi
General contractors
L1c, Avdoo & Partners ConstructionHeld the general construction permit on DOB job 321386175
Interior designer
INC Architecture & DesignReported by e-architect.com
Buyer's lenders
Citizens Bank, Popular Bank, The Federal Savings Bank, Wells FargoThe sponsor's preferred mortgage lenders; you can use another, though the mortgage contingency is offered through the sponsor's lender · Named on p. 19

From our research: What Does a Title Agency Do, and How Do You Pick One for a NYC Condo?

Zoning

Zoning district
C4-4D
Special district
Special Gowanus Mixed-Use District (G)

Today's zoning, from city data (PLUTO 26v2).

Nearby

Free in ChatGPT or Claude

Ask Claude or ChatGPT about Saint Marks Place

The fastest way to know any condo or co-op

Get Connected →
The Condo Book Project Are Saint Marks Place's common charges high for the area? No, they're on the low side. Saint Marks Place budgets $0.85 per square foot a month, against a $0.92 median for the 10 most similar Brooklyn plans.Schedule A Do you want to see the list of similar buildings?
Free: all 106 units, every budget line, every saleSee it free